The Keenan Blog

Blog

Rethinking Health Plan Design: Is ICHRA the Right Fit for Your Organization?

Managing employee benefits has become increasingly complex. Rising health care costs, changing utilization patterns, and the potential for high-cost claims continue to challenge employers, particularly public agencies, schools, community college districts, and health care organizations working within fixed budget environments.

While traditional fully insured plans offer predictability, that stability often comes at a higher cost. Self-funded arrangements can provide greater flexibility and savings opportunities, but they also introduce financial variability. As a result, many employers are evaluating alternative strategies that balance cost management with budget certainty.

One option attracting increased attention is the Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA).

Why organizations are exploring new approaches

Today's benefits environment requires organizations to manage more than annual premium increases. Employers are also navigating evolving workforce expectations, regulatory requirements, and increased pressure to maximize every benefits dollar.

As organizations evaluate their long-term benefits strategies, many share two common objectives:

• Gain greater visibility and control over health care spending
• Reduce financial volatility from year to year

Rather than relying on a one-size-fits-all approach, employers are increasingly exploring plan designs that provide flexibility while supporting organizational and workforce goals.

Understanding ICHRA

An Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA) allows employers to reimburse eligible employees for individual health insurance premiums and qualified medical expenses instead of sponsoring a traditional group health plan.

With an ICHRA:

• Employees select individual health coverage that best meets their needs
• Employers establish a defined reimbursement amount
• Reimbursements may be provided on a tax-advantaged basis when structured in accordance with applicable regulations

This model shifts the employer's role from managing a group health plan to providing a defined contribution that employees can use toward their personal health coverage.

Potential benefits of an ICHRA strategy

For organizations seeking greater financial predictability, ICHRA may offer several advantages.

More Predictable Budgeting

Employers determine reimbursement amounts in advance, creating a defined and controllable benefits expense. This approach can help support long-term financial planning and reduce exposure to unexpected claim fluctuations.

Reduced Claims Volatility

Because employees obtain coverage through the individual insurance market, claim activity is no longer tied directly to the employer's health plan. This can be particularly attractive for smaller organizations or groups that have experienced significant claim variability.

Greater Flexibility

Within regulatory guidelines, employers may structure contributions for different classes of employees, such as full-time, part-time, seasonal, or other eligible groups. This flexibility can help organizations align benefits offerings with workforce needs and budget priorities.

Enhanced Employee Choice

Employees have the opportunity to select coverage based on their unique circumstances, including preferred provider networks, plan designs, and premium levels. This individualized approach can provide greater choice while maintaining employer cost discipline.

Important considerations before implementation

While ICHRA can be an effective strategy for some employers, it is not a universal solution. A thoughtful evaluation of organizational goals, workforce demographics, and market conditions is essential before making any changes.

Key considerations may include:

• Workforce demographics and employee coverage needs
• Availability and affordability of individual market options in applicable regions
• Employee communication, education, and enrollment support requirements
• Compliance obligations, including federal notice and documentation requirements

A successful implementation often depends on careful planning, strong communication, and a clear understanding of how the approach will affect both the organization and its employees.

Building a benefits strategy for the future

As employers continue to navigate rising health care costs and budget pressures, alternative plan designs are becoming an important part of the conversation. ICHRA represents one approach that combines defined employer contributions with employee choice, while helping organizations create greater cost predictability.

The right solution, however, depends on each organization's unique objectives, workforce, and financial considerations.

At Keenan, we help public agencies, educational institutions, and health care organizations evaluate benefits strategies that support both fiscal responsibility and employee well-being. Whether exploring ICHRA or other plan design alternatives, a thoughtful, data-driven approach can help organizations make informed decisions with confidence.